Efficiency of measures/activities determined by strategic documents/programs for tourism development

Report ID: 249

The Republic of Croatia, Republic of Macedonia and Hungary are countries where tourism is a major economic sector and they all have adopted strategic documents related to further tourism development.

In 2015, the three SAIs signed agreements on mutual cooperation in the field of tourism, in order to assess whether the objectives related to the development of tourism are achieved. The subject of the agreements was to perform coordinated audit on the efficiency of measures / activities determined by strategic documents / programs for tourism development.

The objective of the coordinated audit was to provide exchange of knowledge, experience and good practice, as well as conclusions and recommendations for promoting tourism development.

The participating SAIs developed a framework of audit areas to be addressed in their national audits. Five audit areas and corresponding audit questions were identified: Legal, strategic and institutional framework for tourism development, Implementation of strategic measures and other activities defined in strategic documents / programs for development of tourism, Monitoring and reporting on the achievement of strategic objectives and the measure impact, Implementation of the Agreement between the Government of the Republic of Macedonia and the Government of the Republic Croatia on cooperation in the field of tourism and Implementation of the Agreement of the Government of Hungary and the Government of the Republic Croatia on cooperation in the field of tourism. 

Parallel Audit of the Preparation for the organisation of the final tournament of the UEFA EURO 2012 European Football Championship - (2007-2008)

Report ID: 312

The European Football Championship is the third largest sporting event after the Olympics and the World Cup. On 18 April 2007 Poland and Ukraine were granted the right to organize EURO 2012, with the Polish Football Association and the Ukrainian Football Federation jointly accepting the offer. 

On 2 May 2007 an agreement on the organisation of the Final Tournament of the UEFA European Football Championship 2010/12 was signed between UEFA and the EURO 2012 organisers, valid until 30 June 2013.  This agreement sets out the requirements for the organisation of EURO 2012 in accordance with UEFA regulations, obligations and guarantees of state authorities and local governments, among others, and contains annexes in the form of: stadium contracts, contracts with EURO 2012 host cities and agreements with ports.

A paralle audit to  "Preparation of Poland for the organisation of the final tournament of the UEFA EURO 2012 European Football Championship" was undertaken on the initiative of the SAIs of Poland and Ukraine. The audit was carried out in the period from September 2008 to January 2009, and covered the period 2007-2008.

The aim of the audit was to assess the implementation, coordination and monitoring and financing tasks related to the preparations of Poland and Ukraine for the organisation of EURO 2012 by the competent authorities, public administration and other entities, including:

1) The organizational activities carried out by the Council of Ministers and the relevant Ministers and the EURO 2012 host cities;
2) Construction or modernisation of stadia and infrastructure: aviation, road, rail, hotel and communication in the EURO 2012 host cities
3) Development of security and order projects, public and medical security, and promotion of Poland and Ukraine and the EURO 2012 host cities.

* The report is available in Polish and Ukranianource.

** The audit for the period 2009-2010 is also available in the catalogue: https://intosai-cooperativeaudits.org/catalog/report/parallel-audit-of-the-preparation-of-poland-and-ukraine-for-the-organization-of-the-european-football-championship-euro-2012-tournament

INFORME DE AUDITORÍA INTEGRADO DE EVALUACIÓN DE LA REGULARIDAD DE LAS TRANSFERENCIAS OBLIGATORIAS DE RECURSOS DEL FONDO PENITENCIARIO NACIONAL (FUNPEN) A LAS UNIDADES FEDERATIVAS

Report ID: 389

• Esta auditoría se suma a las otras dos importantes inspecciones sobre el sistema penitenciario brasileño, examinado por las sentencias 2.643/2017 (TC 003.673/2017-0) y 972/2018 (TC 026.096/2017-0), del Pleno, en los que se trató específicamente las etapas 1 y 2 de auditoría coordinada con los tribunales de cuentas municipales y estatales, respectivamente.
• Se realizó una auditoría integrada, en las modalidades operativa y de cumplimiento, cuyo objetivo fue evaluar la regularidad y el desempeño de las transferencias obligatorias de recursos del Fondo Nacional Penitenciario (Funpen) a los estados y al Distrito Federal, para verificar en qué medida estas transferencias de recursos han respondido a las necesidades estructurales del sistema penitenciario nacional sistema penitenciario nacional, así como destacar los principales obstáculos para el éxito de la política pública.
• La selección de las Unidades Federales auditadas se basó en la adhesión de las secretarías del TCU en los estados a la fiscalización centralizada, realizada bajo la coordinación de SecexDefesa. Diez unidades técnicas del TCU participaron en los trabajos en los estados de Bahía, Ceará, Minas Gerais, Mato Grosso do Sul, Pará, Pernambuco, Piauí, Paraná, Rio Grande do Sul y Santa Catarina. SecexDefense, además de consolidar las conclusiones de la auditoría en un único informe, realizó una auditoría piloto en el estado de Goiás, UF elegida por el alto nivel de ejecución financiera de los recursos de Funpen. Recursos de Funpen. Secex-Defensa también aplicó los procedimientos de auditoría en el Distrito Federal, lo que hace un total de 12 UF.
• Se abordaron tres preguntas de auditoría, sub divididas en sub preguntas:
• ¿ El sistema de transferencias obligatoria de recursos de FUNPEN es sostenible desde el punto de vista presupuestario y está diseñado para cumplir con los principios de eficiencia y eficacia?
• ¿Los Procedimientos adoptados por el Departamento Nacional Penitenciario (DEPEN) – organismo vinculado al Ministerio de Justicia y Seguridad Pública (MJSP) y por las Unidades de la Federación (UF) en el ámbito de los traslados obligatorios de la fUNPEN son suficientes y adecuados para asegurar la aplicación regular de los recursos?
• ¿El uso de los recursos de FUNPEN en la modalidad de fondo a fondo cumple con la legislación de licitaciones y contratos y con las regulaciones del Depen?

Fuente: https://tcu.jusbrasil.com.br/jurisprudencia/729227607/relatorio-de-auditoria-ra-ra-1804720181/voto-729227895

The results of inspection of utilization effectiveness of state funds allocated for consequences elimination of emergencies

Report ID: 394

The tendency towards the increase of number of emergencies and events, which injure people, damage territories and yield losses to economies, has predetermined the urgency of the issue of providing anthropogenic and ecological safety for societies and territories. Underestimation of harmful factors, as well ass absence of timely compulsory measures is the reason for disastrous consequences, which could have been avoided. This means that health and lives of millions of humans depend on the way functioning of the state general system for prevention and response to disasters and catastrophes is ensured.

During the XIX INTOSAI Congress in Mexico City, the heads of the SAIs of Ukraine and Kazakhstan signed an agreement in order to continue bilateral collaboration that comprised an activity plan for 2008 – 2009. The plan stipulated that both SAIs shall conduct parallel inspections of planning, disbursement and utilization effectiveness of state budget funds, allocated for consequences elimination of emergencies, including anthropogenic disasters.

Among other, the results of inspection showed the inadequacy of communications, warning and information systems of authorized agencies in the area of prevention and consequences elimination of disasters and catastrophes, civil defense, being and important strategic objects of people protection.

Source: https://rp.gov.ua/upload-files/IntCooperation/IntAudits/RI_2008-2009.pdf