Joint audit report Implementation of the Operational Programme Cross-Border Cooperation Republic of Poland – Slovak Republic 2007–2013

Report ID: 341

On 20 December 2007 the European Commission, by means of the decision No C (2007) 6534, approved the Programme. It received support from the European Community by means of the European Regional Development Fund resources for particular borderland areas on the Polish and Slovak sides of the border. The support area of the Programme in Poland included among others: the so called Krosno-Przemyśl subregion and in Slovakia Prešovský Kraj and Žilinský Kraj. Additionally, on the Polish side among others poviat Rzeszów and township Rzeszów were also added to the Programme and could participate in the projects as adjacent areas.

The audit of the Programme was undertaken on the basis of a cooperation agreement concluded on 18 February 1998 between the Supreme Audit Office of Poland (NIK) and the Supreme Audit Office of Slovakia (NKU) – as a result of the joint initiative of NIK Regional Branch in Rzeszów and NKU Expozitur: in Košice and Prešov. The audits were conducted in the periods: November 2009–August 2010 and September 2012–May 2013.

The aim of the audit was to assess the regularity with which and extent to which the Polish and Slovak entities have executed the priorities and goals of the Operational Programme Cross-Border Cooperation Republic of Poland – Slovak Republic 2007–2013,  in particular:
− the effectiveness of the joint organisational structure established in both countries for the
management, implementation and audit of the Programme;
− the execution of particular projects (subjects) within the I and II priority axes of the Programme by the beneficiaries with regard to legality, regularity and economy;
− the achievement of operational goals specified for the particular priority axes.

The axes set were:

I. Development of cross-border infrastructure;

II. Social and economic development;

III. Support of local initiatives (microprojects) and

IV. Technical assistance, in compliance with the partnership obligation.

Source: https://www.nku.gov.sk/documents/10272/1542112/2014+-+Trains+border+cooperation.pdf

Joint Report on the Results of the International Audit on Waste Management and Utilization

Report ID: 366

The International Coordinated Audit on Waste Management and Utilization was conducted in the framework of the EUROSAI Working Group on the Audit of Funds Allocated to Disasters and Catastrophes. The purposes of the national audits – were to assess the state and efficiency of the waste management system in the countries participants of the audit.

The Supreme Audit Institutions (SAIs) of Moldova, Serbia and Ukraine participated in the audit. The SAI of Ukraine was the audit coordinator, The aim of national audits was to assess the state and effectiveness of the waste management system in countries of SAIs– participants of the international audit. The scope of the audit comprised from 2015-2018.

The results of the national audits conducted in the field of household, industrial and other hazardous waste, which can pose a serious threat to human health and the environment, as well as lead to environmental and man-made disasters, showed: for those countries, whose SAIs participated in the audit, common inconsistencies/gaps and problems within existing waste management systems

The results of the cooperative audit indicate the need to strengthen the governments’ efforts to move from the existing linear economy to a circular economy based on the maximum processing of waste generated in the territories of countries as well as the creation of an integrated waste management system in accordance with the EU “waste management hierarchy” in order to reduce the negative impact on the environment, public health and prevent the occurrence of environmental and man-made disasters.

Fuente:  EUROSAI Database of Audits -  https://www.eurosai.org/en/databases/audits/Joint-Report-on-the-Results-of-the-International-Audit-on-Waste-Management-and-Utilization/

INFORME DE AUDITORÍA INTEGRADO DE EVALUACIÓN DE LA REGULARIDAD DE LAS TRANSFERENCIAS OBLIGATORIAS DE RECURSOS DEL FONDO PENITENCIARIO NACIONAL (FUNPEN) A LAS UNIDADES FEDERATIVAS

Report ID: 389

• Esta auditoría se suma a las otras dos importantes inspecciones sobre el sistema penitenciario brasileño, examinado por las sentencias 2.643/2017 (TC 003.673/2017-0) y 972/2018 (TC 026.096/2017-0), del Pleno, en los que se trató específicamente las etapas 1 y 2 de auditoría coordinada con los tribunales de cuentas municipales y estatales, respectivamente.
• Se realizó una auditoría integrada, en las modalidades operativa y de cumplimiento, cuyo objetivo fue evaluar la regularidad y el desempeño de las transferencias obligatorias de recursos del Fondo Nacional Penitenciario (Funpen) a los estados y al Distrito Federal, para verificar en qué medida estas transferencias de recursos han respondido a las necesidades estructurales del sistema penitenciario nacional sistema penitenciario nacional, así como destacar los principales obstáculos para el éxito de la política pública.
• La selección de las Unidades Federales auditadas se basó en la adhesión de las secretarías del TCU en los estados a la fiscalización centralizada, realizada bajo la coordinación de SecexDefesa. Diez unidades técnicas del TCU participaron en los trabajos en los estados de Bahía, Ceará, Minas Gerais, Mato Grosso do Sul, Pará, Pernambuco, Piauí, Paraná, Rio Grande do Sul y Santa Catarina. SecexDefense, además de consolidar las conclusiones de la auditoría en un único informe, realizó una auditoría piloto en el estado de Goiás, UF elegida por el alto nivel de ejecución financiera de los recursos de Funpen. Recursos de Funpen. Secex-Defensa también aplicó los procedimientos de auditoría en el Distrito Federal, lo que hace un total de 12 UF.
• Se abordaron tres preguntas de auditoría, sub divididas en sub preguntas:
• ¿ El sistema de transferencias obligatoria de recursos de FUNPEN es sostenible desde el punto de vista presupuestario y está diseñado para cumplir con los principios de eficiencia y eficacia?
• ¿Los Procedimientos adoptados por el Departamento Nacional Penitenciario (DEPEN) – organismo vinculado al Ministerio de Justicia y Seguridad Pública (MJSP) y por las Unidades de la Federación (UF) en el ámbito de los traslados obligatorios de la fUNPEN son suficientes y adecuados para asegurar la aplicación regular de los recursos?
• ¿El uso de los recursos de FUNPEN en la modalidad de fondo a fondo cumple con la legislación de licitaciones y contratos y con las regulaciones del Depen?

Fuente: https://tcu.jusbrasil.com.br/jurisprudencia/729227607/relatorio-de-auditoria-ra-ra-1804720181/voto-729227895

Coordinated Audit on “Transboundary movements of waste in the light of the Basel Convention provisions” by the Supreme Audit Institutions of Poland, Slovak Republic and Ukraine (2nd Edition)

Report ID: 390

The European Union has incorporated the Basel Convention into the Waste Shipment Regulation. It applies automatically and uniformly in the Member States of the European Union without the need for transposition into national law. The regulation is binding to all Member States in its entirety.

In  2007, the Supreme Audit Institutions (SAIs) of Poland, Ukraine and Slovakia carried out a cooperative audit on transboundary movement of waste between their countries on compliance of international obligations in the management of hazardous waste across the borders of their states.

Taking into consideration some changes in the provision and in order to assess the state of implementation of recommendations included in the first audit, as well as assessing the scope of compliance with the provisions of the “Basel Convention on the Control of Transboundary Movements of Hazardous Wastes and their Disposal”, the SAIs of Poland, Slovakia and Ukraine agreed to re-conduct the joint international audit within the activities of the EUROSAI Working Group on the Audit of Funds Allocated to Disasters and Catastrophes.

The Coordinator of the audit was the Supreme Audit Office of the Republic of Poland. Period covered by the audit 2015 – 2019 Audits were conducted in Poland, Slovakia and Ukraine in the second half of 2019.

The audit objective was to assess the reliability and effectiveness of activities carried out by authorities responsible for transboundary movements of wastes, including within the international cooperation, in particular: y national authorities competent for auditing procedures applied in transboundary movements of wastes; y national environmental protection authorities competent for auditing entities that dispatch or receive wastes from other countries; y national authorities, in particular border authorities, customs services etc., in the scope of auditing the compliance of the notified type of wastes with the actual content of cargo transported across the border.

Source: https://www.nku.gov.sk/documents/10272/1542112/Final+report+Pol-Slo-Ukr-Ang+2021+v7.pdf

The report of the first edition of the audit is available at:  https://intosai-cooperativeaudits.org/catalog/report/joint-information-on-the-results-of-transboundary-movement-of-waste-between-ukraine-the-republic-of-slovakia-and-the-republic-of-poland-2004-2007-in-the-light-of-the-basel-convention

The national report issued by SAI Slovakia on this second audit is available at: https://intosai-cooperativeaudits.org/catalog/report/2019-final-report-transboundary-movement-of-waste-according-to-basel-convention